I come across it so often now, and I notice it with other heat pump installers too. It is my number one frustration.
Contractors who lay underfloor heating and then run a pipe to the underfloor heating manifold with an impossibly small diameter. Sometimes combined with several bends and couplings that create an enormous amount of resistance.
Why is that a problem?
Underfloor heating combined with a gas boiler works with a high-temperature (HT) manifold. That is because the boiler produces a high temperature, while underfloor heating is a low-temperature (LT) emitter. An HT manifold uses a pump to mix the water coming from the boiler with the cold return water from the underfloor heating. This way the boiler water of 60 – 70 degrees is mixed down to the 40 – 45 degrees that goes into the floor. The difference in temperature between the flow and return pipes to the boiler is then roughly 20 – 30 degrees.
If we switch to a heat pump, a flow temperature of 35 degrees or lower is what we want. The great thing about underfloor heating is that 35 degrees is ideal. There are several projects where the underfloor heating has actually started working much better in combination with the heat pump.
Heat Geek installers replace the high-temperature manifold with a low-temperature manifold without a pump.
This means the heated water from the heat pump goes straight into the floor. It also creates a very good buffer for the heat pump installation, so installing a separate buffer is then almost always unnecessary.
The only condition for making this work is that the pipework to the underfloor heating has a decent diameter. That means 2 or 3 sizes larger than what is usually installed. Because there is no more mixing, the difference between flow and return becomes 5 – 7 degrees. That means that to transfer the same output to the floor, you need a flow rate 4× higher than in the high-temperature situation.
It is important that contractors start taking this into account, especially because customers regularly ask explicitly for underfloor heating that is also suitable for a heat pump. That means pipework with a large enough diameter and as few couplings as possible. This keeps the resistance lower, so the pump in the heat pump can get the heat into the home properly. As a general rule, you could use at least 22 mm for 2 to 5 underfloor heating zones and at least 28 mm for 5 to 10 zones. For more than 10 zones I would even recommend 35 mm.
My number one frustration
Replacing a manifold is one thing. Having to replace all the pipework, where newly plastered walls have to be opened up, or a completely new route has to be worked out to install a heat pump, could simply have been avoided by thinking one step further. This is also often a reason why projects don’t go ahead.
Do you recognise this as a homeowner?
As a customer, you can recognise this problem if you have underfloor heating, have done the 50-degree test, and the ground floor heats up less easily. The HT manifold is then your limitation, especially if it is connected with too small a diameter.
You do the 50-degree test by limiting your boiler to a flow temperature of 50 degrees. That way you can see how the installation responds to lower flow temperatures. This test is often seen as the way to find out whether a home is suitable for a hybrid heat pump.
The test certainly gives an indication, but as the explanation about underfloor heating above makes clear, it is anything but conclusive. An installation can fail the test and still be suitable for a heat pump (and vice versa).
Replacing just the manifold from HT to LT costs roughly €750 to €1,250. That is a manageable amount and in most cases easy to solve. If the pipework also has to be replaced, the bill depends entirely on the route and how much breaking and repair work is involved. In that case, count on at least €1,000, but it can be considerably higher with newly plastered walls or complex routes. Costs that could have been avoided completely with the right diameter when it was first installed.
Need help or advice with installing underfloor heating, or with adjusting the manifold and/or the pipework? Feel free to get in touch, we’re happy to take a look with you.